Let’s be honest - if you’ve ever gone down the rabbit hole of pet nutrition TikToks or joined a dog owner’s Facebook group, you know just how overwhelming (and occasionally bizarre) the advice can get. From “never feed kibble again” to “raw is the only way” or “your dog needs turmeric and kefir daily,” the internet is bursting with opinions. But what’s really best for your furry companion?
Let’s break down the biggest myths, separate fact from fiction, and explore what you actually need to know about kibble, raw, and homemade pet diets.
π₯£ MYTH 1: “Kibble is basically junk food for pets”
The truth: Not necessarily.
There’s a big difference between bottom-shelf supermarket kibble and high-quality, vet-approved dry food. The cheaper varieties often do contain fillers, artificial colours, and low-grade protein sources. But premium kibbles (look for brands that are AAFCO-compliant and have undergone feeding trials) can be nutritionally complete and safe - especially for busy pet parents who need convenience and consistency.
π Pros:
Long shelf life
Easy to portion
Balanced with essential nutrients
Often includes vet-backed formulas for age, size, or health conditions
❌ Cons:
Some contain additives or preservatives
Less moisture than other diets (can affect hydration)
Tip: Look for “cold-pressed” kibble or “air-dried” alternatives - they’re emerging as better-for-you options that retain more nutrients.
π MYTH 2: “Raw feeding is the most natural and healthiest way”
The truth: Raw diets can be beneficial - but only when done right.
The idea of feeding your dog or cat like their wild ancestors appeals to many, but raw feeding isn’t without risk. Done improperly, it can lead to nutritional imbalances or expose pets (and humans) to harmful bacteria like Salmonella or E. coli.
π Pros:
High protein and moisture content
Minimal processing
May improve coat condition and stool quality
❌ Cons:
Risk of bacterial contamination
Nutritional gaps if not properly balanced
Expensive and time-consuming to prepare
Tip: If you're considering raw, choose commercially prepared raw diets that are tested for pathogens and nutritionally complete - or work closely with a veterinary nutritionist to build a safe plan.
π₯ MYTH 3: “Homemade meals are always healthier”
The truth: Homemade can be wonderful - but not all Pinterest recipes are created equal.
While making your own dog or cat food might sound wholesome, studies still show that over 90% of homemade pet diets found online are nutritionally incomplete. Missing calcium, the wrong phosphorus ratio, or too much fat can lead to serious health issues long-term.
π Pros:
Total control over ingredients
Great for pets with food allergies or sensitivities
Can use human-grade meats and veg
❌ Cons:
Easy to get the balance wrong
Time-consuming
Often more expensive
Tip: Use pet-specific meal prep apps or consult a board-certified veterinary nutritionist to create balanced recipes tailored to your pet's age, breed, and health status.
π₯ Trending in 2025: Social Media Fads You Should Definitely Question
Bone broth “detoxes”: While bone broth is a nice supplement, there’s no evidence your pet needs a “detox.” Their liver and kidneys already do that naturally.
Plant-based diets for dogs: Dogs can survive on a carefully balanced vegan diet, but it’s extremely difficult to get right. It’s not recommended without professional guidance. For cats (obligate carnivores), plant-based is a hard no.
Superfood overload: Turmeric, spirulina, kefir… Yes, they have benefits. But moderation is key - more isn’t always better, and not every trend is safe for pets.
“Human-grade” hype: Just because it's labeled human-grade doesn’t mean it's balanced for pet health. Your fur baby’s needs are very different from yours.
πΆ So… What Should You Feed Your Pet?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It depends on your pet’s breed, age, health, activity level - and your lifestyle and budget.
Here’s a simple checklist to follow:
✔ Choose food that’s complete and balanced (check for AAFCO or FEDIAF standards)
✔ Consider your pet’s life stage (puppy, adult, senior)
✔ Watch out for fad-driven advice that isn’t vet-approved
✔ Don’t fear high-quality kibble
✔ Use raw or homemade diets only if properly formulated
✔ When in doubt, consult your vet or a pet nutritionist
Final Bark: Your Fur Baby Deserves Facts, Not Fads
At the end of the day, feeding your pet is an act of love. Whether you scoop kibble, prep raw meals, or stir-fry chicken and peas from scratch, what matters most is that your fur baby is happy, healthy, and thriving - not what’s trending on Instagram.
Always remember: love is in the details (and the ingredients label).
© 2025 Marlena Pakula. All Rights Reserved.






